This article first appeared on The Guardian web site at this link: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/sep/11/turnbull-and-morrison-dont-talk-about-unemployment-its-a-deliberate-but-dodgy-cop-out?CMP=share_btn_tw
Turnbull and Morrison don’t talk about unemployment. It’s a deliberate but dodgy cop-out
It is a sad state of affairs to realise that the current crop of Australian policymakers have effectively given up on reducing unemployment.
Treasury reckons that the lowest the unemployment rate can go without there being a wages and inflation breakout is around 5.25%. The Reserve Bank of Australia notes something similar, forecasting that even when the economy is growing strongly at an above-trend pace, the unemployment rate will hover between 5 and 6%.
The current unemployment rate is 5.6% or some 728,100 people – enough to fill the Melbourne Cricket Ground about seven times. Given the Treasury and RBA estimates, it looks like Australia will never see fewer than about 700,000 people unemployed.
And it seems to be a peculiarly Australian issue. In the US, the unemployment rate is 4.3%, in the UK it is 4.5%, in Japan it is 2.8%, while in Germany the unemployment rate is 3.9%. And none of these countries are experiencing a wage/inflation problem. Indeed, even with the very low unemployment rate in Japan, wages are actually falling.
In Australia, the unemployment rate is being skewed by a number of longer run structural factors.
The education and training system means that those who are unemployed do not have the requisite skills for the modern Australia economy. Rather than hiring unemployed Australians and thereby reducing the unemployment rate, firms are heavily reliant on imported skilled workers who arrive here via the Temporary Skill Shortage (the former 457) visa program.
In addition to the obvious social benefits of having a highly skilled population, maximising training and educational attainment should be an uncontroversial policy aim. Yet the government imposes cuts to trades training, is underfunding school education, ramping up university fees and forcing those who get a degree to pay for it more quickly.
Such policies will leave significant parts of the population short of skills.
It could be that treasury and the RBA are wrong and the Australian economy can sustain an unemployment rate at 4% or lower, if only the right policies were in place to allow the economy to grow more rapidly.
It is clear the government has also given up on reducing unemployment. Rarely, if ever, do prime minister Malcolm Turnbull or treasurer Scott Morrison talk of unemployment. They speak of “jobs” and “employment” and almost always discuss jobs “created” when looking at the labour market.
This is a deliberate but dodgy cop-out.
Look at these facts.
Since the September 2013 election, which the Coalition won convincingly, 701,100 jobs have been “created”. This appears to be an impressive result that means the government will get reasonably close to its promise to “create” 1 million jobs in five years.
But this is a statistical fraud and a misguided representation of labour market conditions.
While the number of people in employment in Australia has increased by 701,100 since the 2013 election, the number of people unemployed has also risen, by 38,900. The not-to-be-mentioned unemployment rate is effectively unchanged at 5.65% today compared with 5.67% at the time of the election.
These labour market trends of rising employment, rising unemployment and a steady unemployment rate have occurred because the working-age population has increased by around 1.1 million since September 2013. In other words, only about two-thirds of the people who have entered the Australian workforce have got a job.
In these circumstances, it is easy to see why the government’s focus is to talk about rising employment – largely a function of population growth – and not unemployment, which has been little changed for many years.
Unemployment in Australia can and should be below 5% with the right policies.
One only has to look at the wonderful example of Canberra and the Australian Capital Territory. Over the last 20 years, the unemployment rate in the ACT has been between 3 and 5% and has generally been around 3.5 to 4.5%. If Canberra can do it, so too can the rest of Australia.
It must be noted that the ACT workforce has the highest educational attainment of any state or territory. It also has the highest household incomes.
To make meaningful and permanent inroads into unemployment in Australia the economy must, as a minimum, register faster economic growth, the workforce must be well trained and educated, wages need to register steady and sustainable increases and be linked to productivity so that consumers can spend and further boost the economy.
It can and should be done.